Saint Joan as a Theatre of Ideas

George Bernard Shaw’s Saint Joan is widely regarded as a fine example of the theatre of ideas. This form of drama does not merely aim to entertain; instead, it presents serious discussions about important social, moral, or political matters. In Saint Joan, Shaw uses the story of Joan of Arc to argue that individual conscience, when it goes against institutional authority, is often punished. The central idea of the play is the conflict between personal truth and institutions of power and dominance, showing how progress and truth are frequently resisted by the very systems meant to uphold justice. 

In Saint Joan, Shaw presents Joan as a young woman who listens to her own inner voice. She says that God speaks to her through saints like St Michael and St Catherine. Because of these voices, she believes it is her duty to help the Dauphin (the future King of France) and free her country from English control. She does not wait for approval from priests or noblemen. Instead, she follows what she believes is right. This is what we call individual conscience—a person’s own sense of right and wrong. 

Joan’s strong beliefs make her very different from other characters in the play. For example, in Scene II, she meets Captain Robert de Baudricourt and asks him to let her go to the Dauphin. At first, he laughs at her and says that she is just a foolish girl. But she speaks with such confidence and belief that he is eventually convinced. This shows how her personal voice is powerful and deeply felt. 

Her belief also helps her win support from other important men. In Scene III, she goes to the Dauphin, and even though the court is full of priests and nobles, Joan is not afraid. She speaks clearly and directly. She tells the Dauphin that God has chosen him to be King and that he must be crowned in Rheims. She wins his trust not by force or clever tricks, but through her faith and honesty. Her courage and truth come from within her, not from any outside power. 

However, this same strong personal belief also becomes a problem. The Church leaders cannot accept that a simple girl hears God’s voice directly. According to them, only the Church has the right to speak for God. Joan refuses to say that the voices are false, even when her life is in danger. During her trial, the judges ask her to obey the Church and deny her voices. But she says: 

It is better to be alone with God. His friendship will not fail me, nor His counsel, nor His love.” (Scene V) 

This shows that Joan puts her conscience above all else—even above her safety. She believes that her duty to God is stronger (and more important) than her duty to any human authority. This is why she is punished. The Church sees her as disobedient and dangerous, even though she is honest and sincere. 

Through Joan, Shaw shows how difficult it is to be true to oneself in a world controlled by powerful institutions. Joan listens to her inner voice and acts with great bravery, but the world around her does not accept her independence. Shaw wants the audience to reflect on this question: Should a person be punished for following their conscience—that is, for doing what they believe is right—just because it goes against tradition or laws upheld by institutions of power? 

Another important aspect worthy of a thought is that in many plays or stories, there are clear heroes and villains. However, Shaw does not show the Church leaders or the political figures as simply evil people. He presents them as thoughtful men who believe they are doing the right thing. They are afraid that Joan’s actions could break the order of society and bring confusion. This makes the play more serious and thoughtful, as it asks us to understand both sides of the conflict. 

For example, in Scene VI, we see Joan on trial for heresy (wrong beliefs). The Church officials, like the Bishop of Beauvais and the Inquisitor, speak politely and calmly. They do not shout or act cruelly. Instead, they try to explain that Joan’s voices cannot be trusted and that only the Church has the right to guide people. They believe that if everyone starts listening to their own voices, there will be no order or peace in the world. 

This shows that the Church does not want to destroy Joan out of hatred. They are trying to protect the structure of the world they believe in. They feel that Joan’s ideas are too dangerous: 

THE ARCHBISHOP. She disturbs my judgment too: there is a dangerous power in her outbursts. (Scene V) 

During the trials, the Church officials offer Joan many chances to change her mind. They tell her to sign a statement that says she pretended listening to voices from God and will now follow the Church’s teachings:  

LADVENU [reading quietly] ‘I, Joan, commonly called The Maid, a miserable sinner, do confess that I have most grievously sinned…I have pretended to have revelations from God…I confess to the sin of sedition, to the sin of idolatry, to the sin of disobedience, to the sin of pride, and to the sin of heresy. All of which sins I now renounce and abjure and depart from…And I will never return to my errors, but will remain in communion with our Holy Church and in obedience to our Holy Father the Pope of Rome.’ 

At first, Joan agrees because she is frightened of being burnt. But later, she takes back her words: 

JOAN. Light your fire: do you think I dread it as much as the life of a rat in a hole? My voices were right…I know that your counsel is of the devil, and that mine is of God. 

Her bravery makes the Church officials feel uneasy. Although they do not enjoy punishing her, but they feel they must. They see her as a threat to their authority. This is why they finally decide to burn her at the stake. 

Shaw does not want the audience to simply hate the Church. Instead, he wants us to understand the tragedy of the situation. Joan is honest and faithful, but the Church is afraid of losing control. Both sides believe they are right, but this leads to a tragic ending. By showing this, Shaw presents an important idea: good people can make terrible decisions when they are trapped in old systems and beliefs and deny to shun their bigotry. The real problem is not only bad people, but the powerful institutions that are afraid of the change because they know that this change will soon deprive them of their authority and dominance over the masses. 

Furthermore, the play examines the idea that those who are ahead of their time are rarely understood or accepted: 

JOAN. O God that madest this beautiful earth, when will it be ready to receive Thy saints? How long, O Lord, how long? 

Joan is a modern thinker in a medieval world. She speaks of nationalism, challenges gender roles, and relies on her personal relationship with God rather than religious hierarchy. These ideas, though valuable, are not accepted in her society. Shaw’s argument is that change is slow and painful, and those who bring it often suffer. This again makes Saint Joan more than just a historical play—it becomes a discussion on human progress, belief, and resistance. 

So Saint Joan can be easily taken as a prime example of the theatre of ideas because it places deep moral and social questions at the heart of its plot. Shaw uses Joan’s life to argue that institutions often fail to recognise truth when it comes from an individual. He shows that new ideas are often punished before they are accepted. By encouraging the audience to question authority and think about the value of personal belief, Shaw turns a historical story into a thoughtful examination of conscience, power, and change. 

If you are looking forward to prepare for UGC NET/JRF, you may find this article useful.

Here is a detailed list of topics you need to cover for your NET preparation.

Want to check your UGC NET/JRF preparation? Take these fun and engaging quiz to see how well you’re doing!

©2025. Md. Rustam Ansari [profrustamansari@gmail.com]